So today was spent in and out of the house, driving to the city, and working on the well pump. Seems that our old pump was on it's last leg and the cold night just sorta pushed it over the edge....
We ended up driving into "the city" (Fayetteville) to purchase a new well pump and installing it, along with the heat tape and a heating light with a thermostat to keep it from freezing. The new pump creates the pressure needed to push the water through the house with no issues; a welcome sight! The shower now actually feels like a shower, not like standing in a yard sprinkler, and the hand sprayer on the kitchen sink now sprays across the room!!!!